Saving the World with User-centric Identity.

UX and OpenID the hickups are beginning

The weather that Tom brings us on OpenID is mixed but good in the long run. He says that community is what counts :)

Here's what I learned enabling the sites with OpenID:The Good: OpenID registration is a beautiful thing. The legacy registration page on Stuffopolis can be scrapped. Once that happens, validating email addresses, requiring passwords and lost password security questions for new members will be forever outsourced to the OpenID providers (those that your website trusts).

The Bad: When introducing OpenID, it is a breeze for new members coming to the site, but it can be a little confusing for existing members who registered with the legacy credentials. When those existing members find out about the OpenID option, instead of logging in with the legacy credentials to add the OpenID to their account, they often log in with their new OpenID instead. This log-in will attempt to create a new account by fetching simple registration data from their identity provider. If their email address (sent by their identity provider) matches the one already registered with their legacy account, they can be given some instructions, but sometimes it doesn't match and now we have a problem because if they go back and log in with the legacy credentials, they can't associate their new OpenID to it because another account (the one they accidentally created) now has that OpenID.

Update 12/17: What I need to do is when a member goes to his profile page and attempts to modify his OpenID, after a successful OpenID authentication, if the site detects that there is another account with the same OpenID, then the site will ask the member to confirm that he wants the other account deleted, making sure there is only one account with that OpenID.

The Ugly: Now that some popular open source packages (wordpress, mediawiki, phpBB) support OpenID, the software should honor each other's OpenID sessions so that someone who logs into mediawiki with his OpenID doesn't get presented with an OpenID login form when he visits phpBB, for instance. Although this isn't a huge problem, it is a little ugly and it seems it will require a standard way of registering OpenID apps on a system so that an OpenID session state change in one app will inform the others.

In a nutshell: OpenID is still immature, but it has an extraordinarily committed community behind it and when it comes to software, that's what counts.

Digg This
Reddit This
Stumble Now!
Buzz This
Vote on DZone
Share on Facebook
Bookmark this on Delicious
Kick It on DotNetKicks.com
Shout it
Share on LinkedIn
Bookmark this on Technorati
Post on Twitter
  • Share/Bookmark

Related posts:

  1. Plaxo is becomes OpenID relying party Tonight.
  2. XFN, Liberty 2.0 and OpenID UX
  3. "THE" OpenID - MSFT announcement @ RSA
  4. Corporations plan to contribute Open Source OpenID
  5. Facebook joins OpenID Board

Printed from: http://www.identitywoman.net/ux-and-openid-the-hickups-are-beginning .
© Kaliya Young Hamlin 2010.

Leave a Reply

  • Latest Tweets


    • She's Geeky NYC registration is LIVE!!! super early bird only lasts for a week http://bit.ly/bKOUxl 2 days ago

    • @pamelarosiedee has a post inspired by the lastest women in technology kerfullful. http://bit.ly/dCwFrL 2 days ago

    • I just posted more information about or DC venue for IIW - http://bit.ly/cja7SP 3 days ago

    • "Help" I am saving illustrator images as Jpg. that start out white then turn grey-black. what to do? 5 days ago

    • hi @RobBonta thanks for the follow cause I live in Alameda. Bad news is I can't vote I am Canadian (for now). 5 days ago

    • I went to your site @redjotter and like what I see there. I think focus on service design will be key for "identity" & #vrm services 5 days ago

    • @jayhori you mean the one in NYC? we are still trying to find a venue that doesn't cost the moon. 7 days ago

  • Archives

    • 2010 (16)
    • 2009 (82)
    • 2008 (112)
    • 2007 (167)
    • 2006 (300)
    • 2005 (189)
  • Categories

    • Active Clients (1)
    • Art (1)
    • Articles in other Publications (1)
    • Biometric (2)
    • Books/Papers on ID (7)
    • Business Cases (2)
    • Canada (5)
    • Community (1)
    • Community Dinner (2)
    • Community Management (2)
    • Digital Death (1)
    • Electronic Beacons (1)
    • Enterprise ID (1)
    • Environment (2)
    • Event Annoucements (11)
    • Event Review (7)
    • Facebook (4)
    • Facilitation (1)
    • Freedom (1)
    • Future (11)
    • Government (7)
    • ID Protocol (10)
    • Identitification (6)
    • Identity Commons (5)
    • Identity Gang (9)
    • Identity Layer (4)
    • Identity Rights (7)
    • IIW (14)
    • Industry Commentary (9)
    • Industry Developments (16)
    • Innovation (5)
    • Interesting (7)
    • interop (3)
    • Kids (1)
    • Legal Cases (4)
    • Legislation-Regulation (2)
    • me (6)
    • Media Commentary (5)
    • Media Coverage (2)
    • Mobile (1)
    • National ID (7)
    • Non-US (2)
    • NPTech (2)
    • Open Source (3)
    • Past Lessons (5)
    • Physical Devices (2)
    • Presos/Podcasts/Videos (19)
    • Privacy (14)
    • Representational Systems (1)
    • reputation (3)
    • Reputation Currents (2)
    • She’s Geeky (2)
    • Social Implications (2)
    • Social Network (7)
    • Tool Usage (9)
    • Uncategorized (771)
    • unconferences (2)
    • User Centrism (3)
    • Virtual World (1)
    • visionary (1)
    • What is Identity? (6)
    • Women (3)